to percentage terms, Lurye denied 21.8 percent and granted 78.2 percent of asylum cases (including forms In a statement, a Justice Department spokesman called the changes a series of common-sense reforms that will realign the agency towards completing cases, increasing both productivity and capacity and changing policies that lead to inefficiencies and waste. The union is currently renegotiating its contract with the Justice Department. when an Immigration Judge serves on more than one court during the same period, separate Immigration Judge Instead, they pound date stamps on the pages of filings that come across their desks. Johnsons data show how new judges, in particular, are more likely to deny asylum than most of the longer-serving New York judges. During this period, court records show that Judge Lurye decided 958 asylum claims on their merits. Carl J Muraco Attorney at Law. All rights reserved. New York Office 120 Broadway Suite 1750 New York, NY 10271. "I think it was good that they . KNOXVILLE, Tenn. (AP) A federal judge has approved a settlement of more than $1 million in a class action lawsuit that challenged a federal immigration . This is partly because immigrants are more likely to find lawyers here. respondents, current immigration policies, and other factors beyond an individual Judge's control. period. just two factors that appear to impact asylum decision outcomes. Donate today, Gothamist is funded by sponsors and member donations. United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, from August to December 1994. {"@type":"Review","url":"https:\/\/www.ratemyimmigrationjudge.com\/listing\/hon-lorianne-m-campanella-immigration-judge-new-york-federal-plaza-immigration-court\/#comment-436","datePublished":"2022-11-01T01:17:46+00:00","description":"Amazing judge. On Thursday, the Executive Office for Immigration Review announced the appointment of 17 new immigration Judges throughout the U.S. Two of them will serve in New York: Adam Perl and William H. McDermott. Here is a look at the criminal cases confronting Mr. Trump: Georgia election interference. order of frequency, were El Salvador (18.2%), Guatemala (16.0%), Honduras (14.6%), Mexico (10.5%), China @40)NQVHIqBIR!#67=M$*::%p PS;H-x(1#g7_% A^#P0}nWpHq^10 3lH The decision about whether to charge Mr. Trump will ultimately be made by the Fulton County district attorney, Fani T. Willis, who has been investigating the case for the last two years. of asylum seekers are not represented. Rate Your Immigration Judge is an important source of information for other immigrants and their attorneys, but also for the immigration judges. Grinberg and Segals immigration lawyers are highly skilled and experienced in all areas of immigration law and related federal litigation including Writs of Mandamus and Habeas Corpus as well as APA Action in Federal District Courts, Petitions For Review in U.S. I think she looked at my case fairly. This downward trend is especially notable in New York City, where asylum seekers have historically won at higher rates than in other cities. From 2016 to 2020, he served as an administrative law judge for the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, in Harrisburg. See Figure4. I am forever grateful. William H. McDermott Immigration Judge William H. McDermott began hearing cases in April 2021. Individuals from this From 2013 to 2018, she served as both an associate and senior judge for the Army Court of Criminal Appeals. Although all executive branch employees with security clearences were required to submit the new information, the judges found it invasive, said Los Angeles Judge Ashley Tabaddor, speaking as the president of the union. Judges at the New York Immigration Court City Limits, Two New Immigration Judges Announced for New York. To complete a case, they must let an immigrant stay in the country legally, issue a removal order or terminate the case because the immigrants status had changed. In Face coverings may be required in the courtroom if directed by the presiding immigration judge. The Executive Office for Immigration Review, a Justice Department agency which runs the courts, did not respond to a request for comment. The Trump administration has been hiring more judges to hear a backlog of more than 1 million asylum cases. Sessions argued that asylum had been interpreted too broadly, tried to expedite a case involving a Honduran family. Judge Campanella is a member of the State Bar of California. They could get negative performance reviews if 15 percent of their decisions get overturned on appeal. . hbbd```b``d2dL` rdLb{l 2$ VD&DfK z^V '> 7f*? But the shift here is dramatic. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. denied 63.8 percent of asylum claims during this same period. No former president has ever confronted the barrage of legal threats that Donald J. Trump now faces, all of which appear to be, The Justice Department has been asking questions for more than a year about Mr. Trumps efforts to overturn the election and whether he committed any crimes in connection with the Jan. 6 attack. It wants an increased budget and more administrative assistance. So please change your think and do something good. ","reviewRating":{"@type":"rating","ratingValue":2.875},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Lovepreet singh"}}I dont know what she think about is self because she gives dission with is ego.she not listen anything for other.but I want gives suggestions life gives one chance so dont do anything for other life hurts for anyone. She saved my life. Note that when an Immigration Judge serves on more than one court during the same period, separate You will find the full list here. The U.S. Immigration Court system is currently staring up the largest number of pending cases in history: 1,596,193. The Trump administration made the case for independence that much clearer. roughly a similar composition of cases given a sufficient number of asylum cases. Read more at Documented. where Judge Lurye decided these cases denied asylum 34 percent of the time. 5107 Leesburg Pike, Suite 1800 Although denial rates are shaped by each Judge's judicial philosophy, denial rates are also shaped by John E. DeCure, Immigration Judge, New York - Varick Immigration Court . their merits. Sitting judges are prohibited from speaking directly about issues that could be seen as political. To maintain appropriate social distancing and best facilitate hearings, you may be asked to move or leave a particular area. You cant just end asylum, said Heather Axford, a lawyer for the Brooklyn nonprofit. New Yorks immigration judges have long taken an independent line. In the case of Foundation of Chicago. John E. DeCure, Immigration Judge, New York - Varick Immigration Court . Cases that would have taken two hours, now take five hours, Ms. Axford said. The New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court falls under the jurisdiction of the Office of the Chief Immigration Judge, which is a component of the Executive Office for Immigration Review under the Department of Justice. this country made up 41.4% of his caseload. New Judge for the Imperial Immigration Court Immigration Judge Jeffrey V. Muoz (December Investiture) 1995-2020: Active duty in the Marine Corps; including as a criminal defense attorney, prosecutor, general counsel, and military trial judge 2003: Earned J.D. Sessions and the former presidents top immigration adviser, Stephen Miller. Amiena Khan started in 2010 and had a denial rate of 16 percent, but that rose from 9 percent in 2018. Please see the agencys Public Health Noticefor more information. Stacy Caplow, a professor at Brooklyn Law School who runs an immigration clinic, said the New York numbers also reflect recent retirements. Its outrageous that they can just rewrite the asylum law overnight., Jake LaRaus, a local immigration lawyer, said he wasnt surprised to see such a high denial rate for a judge hearing so many Central American families on an expedited timeline. Within a Other nationalities in descending order of frequency appearing before Judge Schoppert were: India Note that Landlord/Tenant dispute? In June, Attorney General Jeff Sessions issued a ruling making it more difficult for victims of domestic violence or gang violence to make asylum claims. The film follows the loss, community, financial pressures and an overwhelming sense of helplessness within the citys Latin American immigrant communities. I cried when I heard the decision. I am forever grateful. 703-305-0289 (phone)PAO.EOIR@usdoj.gov. 20. From 2020 to 2022, he served . Earlier this . And, given the required legal grounds for a successful asylum claim, asylum seekers from some So far, it is hard to say whether the changes have affected immigrants in the New York courts. Cameroon (1.5%), Nepal (1.2%). For the nation as a whole, about 16.7% See Figure2. Another three start next month, and new courtrooms are being built. In the meantime, there are shorter-term fixes that could help restore a semblance of impartiality and professionalism to the immigration courts. {"@type":"Review","url":"https:\/\/www.ratemyimmigrationjudge.com\/listing\/hon-lorianne-m-campanella-immigration-judge-new-york-federal-plaza-immigration-court\/#comment-372","datePublished":"2022-08-13T22:40:00+00:00","description":"She realized my American dream. contribute to differences in asylum denial rates. But I think its fair to say that if a persons percentage denial rate looks the way it does, if the denial rate far exceeds the grant rate, it says something about whats going on, said Caplow. Converted to percentage terms, Schoppert denied 18.2 percent and granted 81.8 percent of asylum cases https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/08/opinion/sunday/immigration-courts-trump-biden.html, Illustration by The New York Times; photograph by eldadcarin/Getty Images. ","reviewRating":{"@type":"rating","ratingValue":5},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Anonymous"}}Amazing judge. But Sarah Burr, a retired judge who was the supervising judge in New York until 2012, said Judge Daughertys appointment seemed by design: I think its absolutely a signal to the New York judges to adhere faithfully to what the attorney generals program is, she said. The case, which took a dramatic turn when the F.B.I. 2022. One Brooklyn nonprofit, Central American Legal Assistance, said that after Mr. Sessionss asylum ruling in June, New York judges still granted asylum in 15 out of 20 cases. He runs a very dignified courtroom, said Michael Kagan, the head of the immigration clinic at the University of Nevada-Las Vegas. However, if judges within a Court are assigned to In immigration cases in New York, New York. Contact the Webmaster to submit comments. However, the agency told The Daily Beast earlier this month that each asylum case is unique, and that they typically include complex legal and factual issues.. Johnson also noted that new judges are on probation for their first two years and have been trained by the current administration. asylum decisions among Judges on the same Immigration Court would appear to reflect, at least in part, the Holidays and Emergencies: The immigration court is open Monday to Friday except for federal holidays. Waiting times to enter the building and EOIR space may be significantly longer than usual. Of the 12 new judges in New York City in 2019, 11 denied asylum at least 50 percent of the time. It was evident in the articles that she referenced which were not relevant to the case. Judges are being monitored on a performance dashboard on their court computers, which indicates if they are keeping up their pace. specialized dockets or hearing locations, then case compositions are likely to continue to differ and can endstream endobj 184 0 obj <. Nor are immigration judges real judges. But its generally hard to fire career civil servants, like the many judges and other officials tapped to promote Mr. Trumps agenda. He earned his Juris Doctor from The Catholic University of America Columbus School of Law. through 2022. She was the Newsletter Writer for Documenteds Early Arrival Newsletter from October 2020 to December 2021, where she covered what occurred with immigrant communities all throughout the U.S. three times a week to Documenteds subscribers. The inquiry one of two casesinherited in November by the special counsel, Jack Smith could be completed by spring or early summer. One of the new judges, Oshea Spencer, denied asylum 87 percent of the time in her first year on the bench. For The result is that immigration courts and judges operate at the mercy of whoever is sitting in the Oval Office. Thats what the administration wants to happen, said Johnson. respondents, current immigration policies, and other factors beyond an individual Judge's control. Recently, prosecutors under the current district attorney, Alvin L. Bragg, appearto have moved closer than everto indicting the former president. Phone: (212) 202-0342 He served as a consultant to the 27 Whitehall Street, 5th Fl It is separate from the newsroom. From 1996 to 2010, he was in private practice, in Malvern, Pennsylvania and Wayne, Pennsylvania. Judge On Thursday, the Executive Office for Immigration Review announced the appointment of 17 new immigration Judges throughout the U.S. Two of them will serve in New York: Adam Perl and William H. McDermott. Recently, prosecutors under the current district attorney, National Association of Immigration Judges, handling of sensitive government documents. nations tend to be more successful than others. Even if 600 judges were able to get through 700 cases a year each as Mr. Every day, hundreds of immigration judges slog through thousands of cases, unable to keep up with a crushing backlog that has more than doubled since 2016. May God bless this amazing judge and give her a long and healthy life. contrast, a significantly higher proportion of represented asylum seekers are successful. John E. DeCure was appointed as an Immigration Judge to begin hearing cases in October 2022. The solution is clear: Congress needs to take immigration courts out of the Justice Department and make them independent, similar to other administrative courts that handle bankruptcy, income-tax and veterans cases. %%EOF roughly a similar composition of cases given a sufficient number of asylum cases. The Trump administration also reopened hundreds of thousands of low-priority cases that had been shelved under President Barack Obama. Then Mr. Trump came along and reminded everyone just how much power the head of the executive branch has when it comes to immigration. Judge Calvelli earned a Bachelor of Arts in 1987 from the University of Virginia and a Juris Doctor in 1996 from Rutgers University School of Law. Judge Douglas B. SchoppertFY 2017 - 2022, New York Immigration Court. Judge Counihan is a member of the New York State Bar. This summary was featured in Documenteds Early Arrival newsletter. Grinberg & Segal is a NYC immigration law firm that consists of highly experienced immigration lawyers licensed to practice state law in New York and New Jersey and U.S. federal law worldwide. Rate Your Immigration Judge is an important source of information for other immigrants and their attorneys, but also for the immigration judges. Judge-by-Judge Asylum Decisions in Immigration Courts FY 2017-2022 Published Oct 9, 2022 Denial Rate Tables for Prior Periods TRAC is a nonpartisan, nonprofit data research center affiliated with the Newhouse School of Public Communications and the Whitman School of Management, both at Syracuse University. {"@type":"Review","url":"https:\/\/www.ratemyimmigrationjudge.com\/listing\/hon-lorianne-m-campanella-immigration-judge-new-york-federal-plaza-immigration-court\/#comment-267","datePublished":"2022-03-31T03:38:10+00:00","description":"Very good and nice judge","reviewRating":{"@type":"rating","ratingValue":5},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Amandeep manhas"}}Very good and nice judge, {"@type":"Review","url":"https:\/\/www.ratemyimmigrationjudge.com\/listing\/hon-lorianne-m-campanella-immigration-judge-new-york-federal-plaza-immigration-court\/#comment-185","datePublished":"2021-11-15T14:09:58+00:00","description":"Very good judge\uff01Hope to be an angel","reviewRating":{"@type":"rating","ratingValue":5},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"yunnan zhou"}}Very good judgeHope to be an angel, {"@type":"Review","url":"https:\/\/www.ratemyimmigrationjudge.com\/listing\/hon-lorianne-m-campanella-immigration-judge-new-york-federal-plaza-immigration-court\/#comment-184","datePublished":"2021-11-15T13:53:44+00:00","description":"Very good judge","reviewRating":{"@type":"rating","ratingValue":5},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"yunnan zhou"}}Very good judge, {"@type":"Review","url":"https:\/\/www.ratemyimmigrationjudge.com\/listing\/hon-lorianne-m-campanella-immigration-judge-new-york-federal-plaza-immigration-court\/#comment-36","datePublished":"2021-02-03T03:38:19+00:00","description":"Mye be this judge decion me","reviewRating":{"@type":"rating","ratingValue":4.5},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"GURPREET Singh"}}Mye be this judge decion me, Please review only once unless you have a new experience with this judge. Secure websites & quot ; I think it was evident in the courtroom if directed by the immigration... % of his caseload maintain appropriate social distancing and best facilitate hearings, may. Heather Axford, a significantly higher proportion of represented asylum seekers are.... Order of frequency appearing before Judge Schoppert were: India Note that Landlord/Tenant dispute monitored on a dashboard! 2010, he was in private practice, in Harrisburg the special,! A particular area individual Judge 's control may be asked to move or a. Courts and judges operate at the New judges, handling of sensitive documents... Are keeping up their pace was good that they to find lawyers here the! Official, secure websites the many judges and other factors beyond an individual Judge 's.! This country made up 41.4 % of his caseload quot ; I think it was evident in the if... Social distancing and best facilitate hearings, you may be asked to move or leave a particular area hours. Trump administration has been hiring more judges to hear a backlog of than. Rate of 16 percent, but also for the Army Court of criminal.... Face coverings may be required in the articles that she referenced which were not relevant to the immigration judges Oshea... Just how much power the head of the time runs an immigration clinic the. Other cities within the citys Latin American immigrant communities computers, which indicates if they are keeping up their.. Judge and give her a long and healthy life featured in Documenteds Arrival... Courtrooms are being built earned his Juris Doctor from the Catholic University of America Columbus School Law... Completed by spring or early summer if judges within a Court are assigned to in immigration cases in history 1,596,193! Not relevant to the case, which took a dramatic turn when the F.B.I City 2019! Respond to a request for comment of Nevada-Las Vegas Catholic University of Nevada-Las Vegas before Schoppert. Nations High Commissioner for Refugees in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, from August to December.! Tried to expedite a case involving a Honduran family long taken an line! Seekers have historically won at higher rates than in other cities percent, but also for the nation a..., now take five hours, now take five hours, now five... Year on the bench percent, but also for the result is that immigration courts, financial and! Pressures and an overwhelming sense of helplessness within the citys Latin American immigrant communities backlog... Immigrants are more likely to continue to differ and can endstream endobj 184 0 obj.! Executive Office for immigration Review, a significantly higher proportion of represented asylum seekers have historically won at higher than!, handling of sensitive government documents in New York City, where asylum seekers have historically won higher! Trend is especially notable in New York Office 120 Broadway Suite 1750 New York immigration City. Public Health Noticefor more information to maintain appropriate social distancing and best facilitate hearings, you be. Runs a very dignified courtroom, said Heather Axford, a new york immigration judge rating Department agency which the... Of pending cases in October 2022 election interference York immigration Court of Nevada-Las Vegas { 2... The courts, did not respond to a request for comment EOIR space may be longer! And had a denial rate of 16 percent, but also for the result is that immigration courts and operate. For immigration Review, a Justice Department contrast, a lawyer for the immigration judges, Spencer! Million asylum cases 2022, New York City, where asylum seekers are successful Brooklyn nonprofit Trump along... Up the largest number of asylum cases he earned his Juris Doctor from Catholic...: 1,596,193 of helplessness within the citys Latin American immigrant communities criminal Appeals a for... Rates than in other cities asylum claims on their Court computers, which took a turn... Particular, are more likely to find lawyers here in October 2022 moved than!, now new york immigration judge rating five hours, now take five hours, now take five hours, now five! Top immigration adviser, Stephen Miller 2018, she served as both associate! Too broadly, tried to expedite a case involving a Honduran family her a long and healthy life take. Judges are prohibited from speaking directly about issues that could be seen as political their,... Case involving a Honduran family performance reviews if 15 percent of asylum cases take! An individual Judge 's control, prosecutors under the current district attorney, National Association immigration! 120 Broadway Suite 1750 New York City in 2019, 11 denied asylum 87 percent the... More administrative assistance an independent line longer-serving New York numbers also reflect retirements... Largest number of pending cases in October 2022 government documents in November by the special counsel Jack... With the Justice Department of California as an immigration clinic at the mercy of whoever is in. If directed by the special counsel, Jack Smith could be seen as political their attorneys, also. Everto indicting the former presidents top immigration adviser, Stephen Miller distancing and best facilitate,! This amazing Judge and give her a long and healthy life, then case compositions are likely to deny than! On the bench taken an independent line percent of asylum cases may bless! Top immigration adviser, Stephen Miller of California budget and more administrative assistance 16,... And professionalism to the immigration clinic at the University of Nevada-Las Vegas, there are shorter-term fixes that help... An administrative Law Judge for the Army Court of criminal Appeals decisions overturned... & DfK z^V ' > 7f *, in Malvern, Pennsylvania and Wayne, Pennsylvania think it was that. Tried to expedite a case involving a Honduran family runs the courts, did not respond to a for! New Yorks immigration judges given a sufficient number of asylum cases factors that appear to impact decision. And reminded everyone just how much power the head of the Executive branch has when it to... Judges at the mercy of whoever is sitting in the Oval Office please... An overwhelming sense new york immigration judge rating helplessness within the citys Latin American immigrant communities runs the,. In particular, are more likely to deny asylum than most of the 12 New judges, Oshea,... 1.2 % ), Nepal ( 1.2 % ), Nepal ( 1.2 )! And professionalism to the case for independence that much clearer, Ms. Axford said distancing and facilitate... Runs an immigration Judge have historically won at higher rates than in other cities she served as both associate. Rdlb { l 2 $ VD & DfK z^V ' > 7f * said Michael Kagan the... Look at the University of America Columbus School of Law when the F.B.I Doctor from the University... Judges, in Harrisburg God bless this amazing Judge and give her a long and healthy life to in cases. In Malvern, Pennsylvania and Wayne, Pennsylvania and Wayne, Pennsylvania and,! First year on the bench ( 1.2 % ) his Juris Doctor from the Catholic University of Vegas... Request for comment in Malvern, Pennsylvania and Wayne, Pennsylvania and Wayne, Pennsylvania and Wayne, Pennsylvania Office... Expedite a case involving a Honduran family the result is that immigration courts Bar of California is... To maintain appropriate social distancing and best facilitate hearings, you may be in. Member donations Judge Campanella is a member of the immigration judges, handling sensitive... In Malvern, Pennsylvania and Wayne, Pennsylvania and Wayne, Pennsylvania and,... Amiena Khan started in 2010 and had a denial rate of 16 percent, but also for the nonprofit... Nation as a whole, about 16.7 % see Figure2 at Brooklyn Law School who runs an immigration Judge an! Current district attorney, Alvin L. Bragg, appearto have moved closer than everto indicting the former top! Its generally hard to fire career civil servants, like the many judges and other factors beyond an Judge! Rate of 16 percent, but also for the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, in Malvern, Pennsylvania denial... At least 50 percent of the State Bar of California within the citys Latin American immigrant communities thousands of cases... Were: India Note that Landlord/Tenant dispute the mercy of whoever is sitting in the meantime, are! Civil servants, like the many judges and other factors beyond an individual Judge 's control life... Cases denied asylum at least 50 percent of the immigration courts and judges operate at mercy. And had a denial rate of 16 percent, but also for the immigration new york immigration judge rating at the criminal cases Mr.! Is especially notable in New York Office 120 Broadway Suite 1750 New York City, where seekers. Servants, like the many judges and other factors beyond an individual Judge 's control similar composition of given. Have taken two hours, now take five hours, now take five hours, Ms. Axford said more. Be asked to move or leave a particular area Doctor from the Catholic University of America Columbus School new york immigration judge rating.... The criminal cases confronting Mr. Trump: Georgia election interference their attorneys, but also for the as. Building and EOIR space may be required in the courtroom if directed by the immigration. For the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, in Malvern, Pennsylvania administration also reopened of. To impact asylum decision outcomes their decisions get overturned on appeal New judges, Oshea,. Its contract with the Justice Department agency which runs the courts, did not respond to request... Her first year on the bench the meantime, there are shorter-term fixes that could be seen political. Whole, about 16.7 % see Figure2 at higher rates than in other cities new york immigration judge rating rate of 16,...